Skip to content
SEKISUI XenoTech DD Blog Logo

Four ways to optimize preclinical in vitro data to mitigate risk of late-stage clinical failure

1. Collect high-quality data to make informed, confident go/no go decisions for moving your drug candidate forward

If you need a car for a long road trip, the smart thing to do is to consider your options carefully and choose a vehicle that’s going to be reliable. As you decide, you may have various considerations which will impact your decision—how many people are going on your trip, budget, environmental impact, where you aim to end up. And you may be spoiled for choice; there are a lot of dealerships, makes, models, colors, and sizes to choose from. But you’re likely going to weigh your options carefully and decide what’s most important to you before you make a decision.

When it comes to planning studies for your drug’s preclinical development, even more due diligence is required because the stakes could be huge. You can’t just pull into another dealership and drive out with a new molecule. Data quality, expertise of whoever is conducting the study, and confidence in interpretation of results should be at the top of the list for considerations for safety studies, because inaccuracies or missed red flags early in development could result in big problems or even failure down the road.

2. Design studies carefully; a cut corner or small oversight could lead to a big problem later in development.

“Inadequate ADME properties can be devastating to otherwise good drug activity.”1

Pharmacokinetics and defensible risk assessment can make or break a drug’s chances of success in the clinic. When it comes to avoiding technical and translational pitfalls, preclinical results pointing to possible safety concerns, such as drug-drug interactions or toxicity, should be properly investigated through experiments yielding sound, trustworthy data. To responsibly evaluate risk factors, proper study design of nonclinical studies is of critical importance. This requires careful consideration of early in vitro data and results from other preclinical testing to tailor study designs to appropriately answer questions or build a strong data package for regulatory submission.

When choosing a CRO partner or performing your own in-house studies, make sure you work with someone with enough experience to respond appropriately to unexpected issues in the planning process, who can offer flexibility in assay design to fit specific needs of your molecule, and who can offer a consultative approach to results delivery or submission package advice. When you need IND-enabling studies exploring your compound’s drug-drug interaction (DDI) potential or pharmacokinetic properties, we’ve got you covered.

3. Consider drug-drug interaction (DDI) potential and prioritize pharmacokinetic profile data early in the development pipeline

Regulatory authorities worldwide have continuously underlined the importance of early, thorough investigation of safety-related properties including pharmacokinetics and DDI potential in publications and updated guidance documents to encourage diligent practices in preparation for submission to clinical phases. Preclinical data can be used to maximize patient safety and prevent patients from being unnecessarily excluded from participation in a trial. Early studies in relevant, predictive experimental models to explore drug metabolismdrug transportenzyme inhibition and inductionmetabolite formation, and other factors, each can contribute valuable insight to the overall risk considerations of a drug, helping drug developers make better decisions and anticipate clinical results.

4. Develop a plan to properly investigate unexpected results along the way

Your drug candidate is unique. Throughout the discovery and development process, you’re going to learn a lot about the ways your compound interacts with various proteins and all the interrelated pieces involved in its overall disposition. Anticipating roadblocks can be difficult, but knowing where to turn if you do encounter one is not. Coming up against unexpected issues in development or clinical phase can kill a compound, but in some cases it can be an opportunity for innovative problem solving.

Our pool of in-house and external experts can help you when you find yourself facing ADME and DDI-related challenges. Gap analysis, IND-submission review, synthesis of in vitro data, response to regulatory questions, and other services are all in our wheelhouse. Our hand-picked consultants have extensive experience in the field and have seen and helped navigate many obstacles for drug developers. Give us a call to see if we can find a solution together by matching you with one of our very best.

Late-stage clinical failure is always a risk for drug developers and some circumstances can’t be avoided, but some can. Preparing your team to be proactive, value quality results to base decisions on, and respond well to challenges along the way will help you navigate your drug’s development pipeline and maximize chances of a successful outcome, bringing a novel therapeutic agent to the patients who need it.

Learn more about:

[1] Kenakin, Terry. “Pharmacokinetics I.” Pharmacology in Drug Discovery and Development, Second ed., Academic Press, 2016, pp. 157–191.

About the Authors

Madison (Knapp) Esely-Kohlman received her BS from the University of Missouri – Columbia and is currently SEKISUI XenoTech’s Marketing Communication Specialist, developing scientific content that communicates the value and expertise of internal contract service and test system production teams. Madison joined SEKISUI XenoTech as the Scientific Communications Coordinator in 2019 after serving in similar positions at CropLife America, Bond Life Sciences Center and the University of Missouri CAFNR Office of Communications.

Subscribe to our Newsletter

Stay up to date with our news, events and research

In vitro pipette test article treatment
005 International Messaging Created with Sketch.

Do you have a question or a request for upcoming blog content?

We love to get your feedback

A scientist utlilizing a microplate